128 responses

  1. paul
    November 29, 2007

    holy snap that thing is a beastly deer. i wish i could bag something like that. what u get him with and at what distance???

  2. Zack
    November 29, 2007

    dude that is an awsome buck my dad got one 13 years ago but it was a 28 point and was rad

  3. Zachariah
    December 3, 2007

    That is some buck!

    I see some misunderstandings in the posts. The Amish do not appear in photographs due to the commandment about graven images. Contrary to popular belief, they can and do own firearms (even modern ones) for hunting and agricultural chores.

  4. chris wilson
    December 5, 2007

    Their was a 42 pt. buck hit by a semi in Lima,Ohio the week of Nov.26-Dec.1it’s looks too be a typical. It has too be an Ohio state record buck

  5. hunter
    December 5, 2007

    i killed a buck that went 186 but dang dude thats a monster. i have been watching a monster whitetail he is a state record and he has tines at least 16 inches long but great deer.

  6. Clint
    December 9, 2007

    That is a nice buck!! The person that shot that is spoiled for life. They’re never gonna get another buck like that. Im 15 and i shot a 11 pointer that scored 146 5/8 and i thought that, that one was big, but hey congrats.

  7. Bones
    December 16, 2007

    i am from PA and the first time i heard about this buck i got a picuter from my brother sayin this deer was hit by a truck in ohio…his friends dad took a picture of it……….then i saw it on another website sayin it was killed in wisconsin….now its killed by an amish boy in ohio…i dont know what to belive

  8. mbhunts
    December 18, 2007

    now this is why i stay in my stand hour after hour great bucks like this one make it all worth while tyvm 4 showing him too all of us mark b

  9. 8pt/CH 170
    December 25, 2007

    I have been fortunate enough to see alot 0f nice deer on my farm in northeast OH. but nothing quite as big as this beast.Congrats goes out to this hunter.

  10. Ty
    January 18, 2008

    Ok for one thing we here in ohio hunt fair. Amish are tough some guns here. They wouldn’t do such a thing to pen and then hunt. And I bet Johnathon wasnt even hunting for rack he was hunting for meat. Amish are aloud to hunt with a cross bow I see it all the time. We dont hunt for rack we hunt to put food on the table here in ohio. I live in amish country here, and they just dont get their picture taken, so get over it. Oh and one other thing TV hunting shows some of u hunt in deer pens, why don’t u step ur game up and hunt for real!!!

  11. Michael
    January 28, 2008

    This is a great buck! It’s really nice to see a deer of this size killed within 5 minutes of where I live. The day that this deer was killed I was fortunate enough to get to personally hold this deer in my own hands. Wow what a feeling that was, to be able to hold a record holding deer of that size. It’s a shame that some people are so jealous as to beat on a man for killing something that many never have a chance at even seeing, let alone killing. I think some people need to know the whole story behind this great buck and the man’s personal beliefs before posting some of the comments in which they have.

  12. tj
    May 20, 2008

    there was some guy that said indiana did’nt have big bucks like this one well he is full of crap because you have to look to know and know where they are at…well great job on the deer…

  13. andrew fugate
    July 13, 2008

    great deer i would love 2 killed it. great job man!

  14. branden
    August 28, 2008

    if i shot that buck id ask to put it it the world roerd book

  15. trevor
    November 5, 2008

    thats a very nice buck if i ever seen a buck that big i would not be able to shoot or if i did kill it i probably couldnt get out of the tree stand it is very cool to see a buck that big in ohio around the same area i hunt at.

  16. cody perry
    November 26, 2008


  17. JoeD
    December 4, 2008

    Soo many posts but non state the weight. The weight?

    I was wondering if we hunted like wolves, as in targeting the weak would the heards be healther and there be even larger bucks to look at?

    No, I am not a hunter but I am not against it or owning any gun.
    Congrats to the young man!

  18. Jack Hughes
    December 4, 2008

    could this buck be eligible for any world records?

  19. Tim
    December 7, 2008

    Yes this is one great deer!! I have personaly held it and WOW! The pics dont do it justice. I agree with Cross.There are always rumors flying around on great dear. But before you belief them and pass them on, check on the facts or be silent. Why do we try knock others it is because we want to lift ourselves up. This is only a natural instict in us, if we dont know Jesus as our Savior. Give God the Glory for designing such a beautiful animal to enjoy!!

  20. Dillon Mofford
    December 8, 2008

    now thats one nice deer i wish i could shoot one that big the biggest deer i have shot was a 3 x 4 but im only 13 i still have a lot of years left to hunt congrats to you!!!!!.

    December 12, 2008


  22. jeremy
    December 17, 2008

    nice buck i live in adams county maybe i’ll get one that big

  23. russell steele
    December 20, 2008

    I am in fayetteville tn. Just heard about your deer. I hope i kill one that big one of these days

  24. mike
    January 29, 2009

    nice to see someone kill a buck that is not a so called professional hunter with a tv show ., raising deer with bio. crops were only they and there money people can hunt them.no different then raising cattle .i wonder how many check books from the so called pros would have opened if they new that buck was there.the amish hunter that harvest that buck was a real hunter .

  25. bob
    April 9, 2009

    nice deer

  26. son
    January 23, 2010

    sweet buck

  27. Kyle isom
    November 2, 2010

    That is one monster dear it’s amazing knowing there are whitetails around that are that big.

  28. Load More Comments…

Leave a Reply




Back to top
mobile desktop